Monday, December 27, 2004

FOR HARDCORE BUFFY FANS ONLY

Via Whedonesque, someone has set new words--from the mouths of Angel characters--to the note-perfect melodies of songs from Once More With Feeling (the musical episode, for all you non-fans).

The lyrics are not very good. But this is partly because the original was so intricately created, with internal rhymes and dramatic beats that enhanced the emotional power of the music and character development...there's just no comparison.

Any fan knows that Angel would not have embraced the singing the way these lyrics indicate. His reaction would have been more along the lines of Spike's reluctant croon in OMWF. (Think of the eyeroll when he realizes he's singing to Buffy against his will...precious...) And Fred singing to Angel and Wes (instead of Gunn and Wes) is an odd choice. Interesting to think of Fred's yammering as equivalent to Xander's babbling, though.

Anyway...if you're a fan, great, and welcome! If you're not? So's your face.

3 Comments:

At 12:25 PM, December 28, 2004, Blogger Coelecanth said...

Dang it, you've conflicted me! I own seasons one and six on dvd. I promised myself I'd only watch them in order and only if I got them through work. I pay 30% of retail if I'm patient enough to wait for them to show up here. Now I have to decide: stick to the plan or check out the new lyrics. Thanks.

 
At 1:06 PM, December 28, 2004, Blogger Esther Kustanowitz said...

C--if you don't know the music, the new lyrics won't mean that much to you. I say wait: view them in order, because season six depends on knowledge of all that came before it...

It's worth the wait. Start netflixin'.

 
At 10:14 PM, December 29, 2004, Blogger Dawn Summers said...

Yeah, screw the plan -- get them all post haste!!!

 

Post a Comment

<< Home

My Urban Kvetch: FOR HARDCORE BUFFY FANS ONLY

Monday, December 27, 2004

FOR HARDCORE BUFFY FANS ONLY

Via Whedonesque, someone has set new words--from the mouths of Angel characters--to the note-perfect melodies of songs from Once More With Feeling (the musical episode, for all you non-fans).

The lyrics are not very good. But this is partly because the original was so intricately created, with internal rhymes and dramatic beats that enhanced the emotional power of the music and character development...there's just no comparison.

Any fan knows that Angel would not have embraced the singing the way these lyrics indicate. His reaction would have been more along the lines of Spike's reluctant croon in OMWF. (Think of the eyeroll when he realizes he's singing to Buffy against his will...precious...) And Fred singing to Angel and Wes (instead of Gunn and Wes) is an odd choice. Interesting to think of Fred's yammering as equivalent to Xander's babbling, though.

Anyway...if you're a fan, great, and welcome! If you're not? So's your face.

3 Comments:

At 12:25 PM, December 28, 2004, Blogger Coelecanth said...

Dang it, you've conflicted me! I own seasons one and six on dvd. I promised myself I'd only watch them in order and only if I got them through work. I pay 30% of retail if I'm patient enough to wait for them to show up here. Now I have to decide: stick to the plan or check out the new lyrics. Thanks.

 
At 1:06 PM, December 28, 2004, Blogger Esther Kustanowitz said...

C--if you don't know the music, the new lyrics won't mean that much to you. I say wait: view them in order, because season six depends on knowledge of all that came before it...

It's worth the wait. Start netflixin'.

 
At 10:14 PM, December 29, 2004, Blogger Dawn Summers said...

Yeah, screw the plan -- get them all post haste!!!

 

Post a Comment

<< Home